'Reviews' Blog Post Archive
Review of my book on Presto Music

Review of my book on Presto Music

I was on my way to Wigmore Hall in London for my recital a few days ago when this very pleasing review of my Nocturne book popped up on Presto Music. I think reviews are a new kind of offering on Presto Music, so in case readers haven't come across it, I thought I'd...

read more

Get The Latest Posts

Interested in what Susan has to say about all things classical music? Subscribe below and whenever Susan writes a new blog post you will be notified by email. Simple!

FT Best Summer Books of 2024

FT Best Summer Books of 2024

My book on women pianists has been chosen by the Financial Times as one of their Best Summer Books of 2024. Music critic Richard Fairman made it one of his choices. It's very gratifying to find the book being noticed by a wider circle - I suppose because of the...

read more

Herald review of Milngavie 75th anniversary concert

Four stars from The Herald today for my Glasgow concert with Jamie MacDougall and the Maxwell Quartet, marking the 75th anniversary of Milngavie Music Club with a very special programme: 'To mark the club's 75th birthday, current president Hugh Macdonald introduced a...

read more

Five-star ‘Scotsman’ review of my Queen’s Hall solo recital

I haven't written anything here for a while because I have been busy preparing for a big solo recital programme last Thursday in the Queen's Hall in Edinburgh (and for several 'run-up' concerts in different parts of the country). All went well, and after a very happy...

read more

Reviews: how can we quote them if the press doesn’t print them?

Two recent topics of conversation have come together in my mind to prompt a question. Topic 1: the number of classical concert reviews is shrinking rapidly. Everyone in the profession has noticed it. Many newspapers are reducing the number of classical reviews they...

read more
Reviews of the Mosaiques weekend, Perth

Reviews of the Mosaiques weekend, Perth

A great weekend of music-making in Perth Concert Hall with the Quatuor Mosaiques came to an end yesterday with  fabulous five-star reviews in The Herald and The Scotsman. During the residency we had the privilege of staying in Methven Castle with its delightful...

read more

LCMS review of my book

Excerpt from a review of my book 'Sleeping in Temples', in the newsletter of the London Chamber Music Society (you can download the whole newsletter from their site). 'I don't usually 'judge a book by its cover', but in this case the cover is a lovely place to start:...

read more

The changing status of reviews

The news that Alex Ross is now the only full-time classical music critic on an American magazine has got me thinking about the changing status of reviews. Gone are the days when an 'important' concert would routinely be reviewed by all the major papers. When I was a...

read more

Edward Greenfield: a word of appreciation

Sad news that Edward Greenfield has died. He was senior music critic of The Guardian for many years, and a longstanding contributor to Gramophone magazine. Although 'Ted' was a professional critic, it always seemed to me that he was determined to accentuate the...

read more

Scottish Journal of Performance: book review

'Sleeping in Temples is the fourth book by the pianist and author Susan Tomes. The book is drawn from the author’s memories, experiences and thoughts about the music she has been intensely and sincerely committed to as a pianist performing at the highest international...

read more
Herald review of Aurea Quartet and me

Herald review of Aurea Quartet and me

On Friday I played Mozart's K414 concerto with the Aurea Quartet in the Cottier Festival in Glasgow. Today's Herald carries a delightful review by senior critic Michael Tumelty; as the Herald Online is sometimes tricky for non-subscribers to access, here is the...

read more

Herald review of Friday’s Cottier Chamber concert

Today's Herald carries a review, by senior critic Michael Tumelty, of Friday's Cottier Chamber Project opening night. As the review is only accessible online to subscribers, I'll post it here. Susan Tomes/Daniel's Beard, Cottier's Theatre, Glasgow 'THERE was a...

read more

American Library Association magazine review

My new book has had its first 'review' in the States. 'Choice', the professional magazine of the American Library Association, has recommended it for students, professionals, and general readers. This is a big step forward because 'Choice' is an important influence on...

read more

Gramophone magazine review

The March issue of Gramophone Magazine carries a review of my book 'Sleeping in Temples'. As the review is not available online except to subscribers, here's an excerpt: " 'Out of Silence' [my previous book] was written in diary form. 'Sleeping in Temples' is a series...

read more